Category talk:Fallout 3 radio facilities

Really?
Do we really need this category? I vote for deletion.--Kingclyde 04:39, September 18, 2011 (UTC)


 * I believe the category system is useful as designed only if the categories themselves are neither too broad nor too narrow. While there is an existing category, "Fallout 3 radio stations", its name seems to limit it to only those locations that broadcast radio. In that case, the GNR facility would not qualify (its transmitter is in the Washington Monument), nor would all the satellite uplink facilities (they don't really transmit).


 * The existing "Fallout 3 radio stations" list didn't contain several of the pages I was adding to the "Fallout 3 radio facilities" category.


 * I wouldn't be opposed to merging the two, though I think it makes more sense to put the more-restrictive "radio stations" items into the less-restrictive "radio facilities" list.


 * Although Kingclyde didn't say much about it, I suspect he doesn't want to see duplication and/or overlapping lists. On this we agree.


 * Does anyone else have any thoughts on the matter? Thanks! UncleBubba 05:21, September 18, 2011 (UTC)


 * Merging the two together would indeed be ideal. I'm no that big of a fan of duplication.--Kingclyde 05:29, September 18, 2011 (UTC)