Talk:The Whole Gang's Here

I got this achievement despite not recruiting Lily. Anyone else have a similar thing happen?--75.176.65.153 03:34, October 23, 2010 (UTC)

To get this trophy do you need to recruit all companions in one playthrough and have them all at the same time, or just recruit all of them at leats once in all different save files? File:Oh no he didnt.pngMr Zurkon 08:14, October 23, 2010 (UTC)


 * The game very clearly states that you may have only one humanoid and one non-humanoid companion at any one time. Therefore the intention of the achievement is that you recruit all of them at some point.  As for having to do it in one playthrough, I assume so... could someone please confirm? Blackmonolith 23:57, October 30, 2010 (UTC)

do you need all of them?
which ones do you need to get all of them or just the permanent ones?-Zesbeer

Cass, Cass, a pain in the ass
The article states that if you kill Cass during Birds of a Feather, the achievement will not unlock. I have yet to see if this turns out to be true for my first playthrough as I have a ways to go. But I did indeed turn her into toast during "Birds" (simply because her own quest refused to advance for me, presumably because my klepto-character was so evil).

If this is the case, count me in the pissed-off column, Bethesda/Obsidian. I certainly recruited her as a companion before "Birds" played out, so the achievement should be satisfied. If the bug is persistent, please patch! Thanks. Blackmonolith 00:04, October 31, 2010 (UTC)

Yes, killing and recruiting are two different things. 109.151.136.155 19:14, September 7, 2011 (UTC)

Won with only 7
Like the first poster, I only needed seven, although in my case I was missing Veronica. This was my first game too, so it's not due to the other glitches. Platform was 360. Still new at this, so I'm not sure how much something needs to be verified before adding it to the bugs section. 24.62.59.89 05:13, February 21, 2011 (UTC) Kaz

I hired and rehired companions a couple of dozen times. Despite this, the achievement did not unlock for me until I hired the 8th and final companion (all of the above in the same play-through). The exploit/bug does not work for everyone. In case it makes a difference for replication purposes, I have not reached the Lucky 38 suite. Each dismissed companion reverts to original locations. First playthrough, begun after the second patch. Vault Girl 23 February 2011

Same here, got the acheivement with only 7, Arcade was my odd man out. ScreamingFalcon 13:44, June 13, 2011 (UTC)

Oddly enough, I got it on my first playthrough by having recruited Boone, Rex, and then Veronica. I don't think I even re-recruited any of them, either. --With care and happiness,  Supermutantslayer450'  YOU. LOSE.  13:50, June 13, 2011 (UTC)

how did I wind up with the achievement?
I only have ever recruited Raul and Arcade. I killed Rex (not knowing he was a potential companion until afterward) and haven't even met the rest (that I'm aware of anyway). Yet after playing a few hours last night, I check my achievements (360 ver) and I've got this one for no apparent reason. It's my first playthrough, so it's not even that other bug whereby you might get it after recruiting a total of 8 over multiple plays.76.226.115.214 19:08, 17 April 2013 (UTC)