Forum:Just trying to get a consensus on Jack

I guess I should start by saying that I became bored with the Shishkebob as a melee weapon and instead tried Jack as a substitute. If I am to understand correctly, would the critical strike damage and chance for Jack, upped by the proper perks (better criticals and ninja) and luck make it a prime contender for best melee weapon in the game?

I realize that for the most part it comes down to playstyle, but I am trying to create a character that uses only a single ranged weapon (Blackhawk) and a single melee weapon (Jack).